Padres/Giants

[Das (Former Giants GM)]

Padres receive:
OF Melky Cabrera ($3M, 50% covered in '16) 16:$6M 17:$6M 18:$6M 19:CO $6M
RP Arodys Vizcaino ($5.25M, 75% covered in '16) 16:$7M 17:CO $7M
OF Tyler Naquin (prospect)
SP Jorge Lopez (prospect)
3B Ryan McMahon (prospect)
SP Tyler Anderson (prospect)

Giants receive:
OF George Springer 3 of 7 $.8M
1st rd pick
2nd rd pick
4th rd pick
5th rd pick (boston)

Giants accept.  Talk about being out matched when it comes to wits, I'm coming away really impressed at Matt's ability to negotiate.  I like the package I'm receiving, even though I'm giving up more than I would have thought I liked.  Springer represents a upgrade in talent over Cabrera, even though Cabrera is out performing Springer, I like this addition to my lineup, giving up the prospects is difficult, but I'm hoping that I have the depth to take a risk.  Thanks for the great talks, and to those of you voting, thank you for voting.  Have a great day and best of luck.

[Matt (Former Padres GM)]

I accept. Dealing Springer is a risk but I need to spread the value of that asset and create more depth for my team with guys that are closer to contributing to the MLB. Great negotiations! I have no doubt that with your knowledge you'll put those picks to good use.

[Deleted]

Approve

[Dave (Former Nationals GM)]

Looks like a good deal for both groups- Approve

[D'backs GM (Kyle)]

Approve. That's a lot to give up for Springer, but he is a very talented young controllable piece and those picks COULD end up being more valuable then the specs that are being traded.

[Brewers GM (Tim)]

Approve

[Mariners GM (Phil)]

approve, i agree with Arizona, both risks seem equal

[Guardians GM (Thomas)]

Approve.

[Royals GM (Bill)]

Approve.

[Jerry (Former Yankees GM)]

Approve

[Rockies GM (Alex)]

Approve (9-0)

[Rockies GM (Alex)]

Official. Processed.