Pre-Season Projections Update
Mar 14, 2023 17:15:29 GMT -5
Das (Former Giants GM) and White Sox GM (Caleb) like this
Post by Ken Rosenthal on Mar 14, 2023 17:15:29 GMT -5
A post-Free Agency update. Fantrax updated their player projections again this week.
Statistics from Fantrax Player Projections, adjusted for BKDB regular season stats only.
Players included: Top 50 projected at each position, Top 180 SP, and Top 160 RP.
Criteria: Only best starting lineup included in hitting points. Top 8 SP per team. Top 6 RP per team.
Notes: My opinion is that these rankings will slightly undervalue overall depth on teams. That's the downside of doing these calculations manually. As seen from last year's projection comparisons, they aren't so far off from Will's FanGraphs projections though. Being bullpens are so volatile, these rankings also tend to marginally overvalue teams with elite bullpen arms.
TIER 6: TANKERS
30(22). Philadelphia Phillies
2023 Points Projected: 2,372 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,547
Hitting Rank: 29th | Rotation Rank: 29th | Bullpen Rank: 18th
29(28). Tampa Bay Rays
2023 Points Projected: 2,463 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,095
Hitting Rank: 26th | Rotation Rank: 30th | Bullpen Rank: 29th
28(29). Boston Red Sox
2023 Points Projected: 2,634 | 2022 Points Scored: 2,116
Hitting Rank: 27th | Rotation Rank: 27th | Bullpen Rank: 30th
27(30). New York Yankees
2023 Points Projected: 2,785 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,694
Hitting Rank: 28th | Rotation Rank: 25th | Bullpen Rank: 25th
26(27). Pittsburgh Pirates
2023 Points Projected: 2,926 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,207
Hitting Rank: 30th | Rotation Rank: 22nd | Bullpen Rank: 15th
25. Oakland Athletics
2023 Points Projected: 3,582 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,587
Hitting Rank: 25th | Rotation Rank: 26th | Bullpen Rank: 23rd
24. New York Mets
2023 Points Projected: 3,646 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,453
Hitting Rank: 24th | Rotation Rank: 23rd | Bullpen Rank: 26th
TIER 5: NO MAN'S LAND
23(26). Minnesota Twins
2023 Points Projected: 3,668 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,964
Hitting Rank: 21st | Rotation Rank: 24th | Bullpen Rank: 27th
22(21). Kansas City Royals
2023 Points Projected: 4,282 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,830
Hitting Rank: 22nd | Rotation Rank: 28th | Bullpen Rank: 6th
21(23). Chicago Cubs
2023 Points Projected: 4,587 | 2022 Points Scored: 2,649
Hitting Rank: 20th | Rotation Rank: 20th | Bullpen Rank: 17th
20. Atlanta Braves
2023 Points Projected: 4,593 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,814
Hitting Rank: 18th | Rotation Rank: 21st | Bullpen Rank: 22nd
TIER 4: ON THE PLAYOFF BUBBLE
19(17). Arizona Diamondbacks
2023 Points Projected: 5,092 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,002
Hitting Rank: 14th | Rotation Rank: 19th | Bullpen Rank: 20th
18(19). Milwaukee Brewers
2023 Points Projected: 5,184 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,647
Hitting Rank: 23rd | Rotation Rank: 14th | Bullpen Rank: 8th
17(11). San Diego Padres
2023 Points Projected: 5,313 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,082
Hitting Rank: 19th | Rotation Rank: 11th | Bullpen Rank: 21st
16. Los Angeles Angels
2023 Points Projected: 5,466 | 2022 Points Scored: 5,805
Hitting Rank: 15th | Rotation Rank: 6th | Bullpen Rank: 28th
15(18). Detroit Tigers
2023 Points Projected: 5,490 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,701
Hitting Rank: 11th | Rotation Rank: 18th | Bullpen Rank: 19th
14(15). Miami Marlins
2023 Points Projected: 5,654 | 2022 Points Scored: 5,938
Hitting Rank: 16th | Rotation Rank: 12th | Bullpen Rank: 10th
13(12). Los Angeles Dodgers
2023 Points Projected: 5,720 | 2022 Points Scored: 5,829
Hitting Rank: 6th | Rotation Rank: 13th | Bullpen Rank: 24th
12(14). Colorado Rockies
2023 Points Projected: 5,733 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,105
Hitting Rank: 17th | Rotation Rank: 15th | Bullpen Rank: 14th
11(13). Texas Rangers
2023 Points Projected: 5,815 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,832
Hitting Rank: 4th | Rotation Rank: 17th | Bullpen Rank: 16th
TIER 3: LIKELY TO PUNCH THEIR TICKET
10. Cleveland Guardians
2023 Points Projected: 5,986 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,480
Hitting Rank: 12th | Rotation Rank: 16th | Bullpen Rank: 7th
9(8). Cincinnati Reds
2023 Points Projected: 6,007 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,683
Hitting Rank: 13th | Rotation Rank: 10th | Bullpen Rank: 12th
8(9). Houston Astros
2023 Points Projected: 6,240 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,390
Hitting Rank: 8th | Rotation Rank: 9th | Bullpen Rank: 13th
TIER 2: THE CONTENDERS
7(5). Toronto Blue Jays
2023 Points Projected: 6,666 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,744
Hitting Rank: 7th | Rotation Rank: 1st | Bullpen Rank: 11th
6. St. Louis Cardinals
2023 Points Projected: 6,758 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,096
Hitting Rank: 10th | Rotation Rank: 7th | Bullpen Rank: 4th
5(4). Washington Nationals
2023 Points Projected: 7,057 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,699
Hitting Rank: 5th | Rotation Rank: 2nd | Bullpen Rank: 5th
4(3). Chicago White Sox
2023 Points Projected: 7,127 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,082
Hitting Rank: 9th | Rotation Rank: 4th | Bullpen Rank: 1st
3(7). Baltimore Orioles
2023 Points Projected: 7,172 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,823
Hitting Rank: 3rd | Rotation Rank: 3rd | Bullpen Rank: 9th
TIER 1: THE WORLD SERIES FAVORITES
2(1). Seattle Mariners
2023 Points Projected: 7,346 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,389
Hitting Rank: 2nd | Rotation Rank: 8th | Bullpen Rank: 2nd
1(2). San Francisco Giants
2023 Points Projected: 7,554 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,961
Hitting Rank: 1st | Rotation Rank: 5th | Bullpen Rank: 3rd
Statistics from Fantrax Player Projections, adjusted for BKDB regular season stats only.
Players included: Top 50 projected at each position, Top 180 SP, and Top 160 RP.
Criteria: Only best starting lineup included in hitting points. Top 8 SP per team. Top 6 RP per team.
Notes: My opinion is that these rankings will slightly undervalue overall depth on teams. That's the downside of doing these calculations manually. As seen from last year's projection comparisons, they aren't so far off from Will's FanGraphs projections though. Being bullpens are so volatile, these rankings also tend to marginally overvalue teams with elite bullpen arms.
TIER 6: TANKERS
30(22). Philadelphia Phillies
2023 Points Projected: 2,372 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,547
Hitting Rank: 29th | Rotation Rank: 29th | Bullpen Rank: 18th
29(28). Tampa Bay Rays
2023 Points Projected: 2,463 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,095
Hitting Rank: 26th | Rotation Rank: 30th | Bullpen Rank: 29th
28(29). Boston Red Sox
2023 Points Projected: 2,634 | 2022 Points Scored: 2,116
Hitting Rank: 27th | Rotation Rank: 27th | Bullpen Rank: 30th
27(30). New York Yankees
2023 Points Projected: 2,785 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,694
Hitting Rank: 28th | Rotation Rank: 25th | Bullpen Rank: 25th
26(27). Pittsburgh Pirates
2023 Points Projected: 2,926 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,207
Hitting Rank: 30th | Rotation Rank: 22nd | Bullpen Rank: 15th
25. Oakland Athletics
2023 Points Projected: 3,582 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,587
Hitting Rank: 25th | Rotation Rank: 26th | Bullpen Rank: 23rd
24. New York Mets
2023 Points Projected: 3,646 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,453
Hitting Rank: 24th | Rotation Rank: 23rd | Bullpen Rank: 26th
TIER 5: NO MAN'S LAND
23(26). Minnesota Twins
2023 Points Projected: 3,668 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,964
Hitting Rank: 21st | Rotation Rank: 24th | Bullpen Rank: 27th
22(21). Kansas City Royals
2023 Points Projected: 4,282 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,830
Hitting Rank: 22nd | Rotation Rank: 28th | Bullpen Rank: 6th
21(23). Chicago Cubs
2023 Points Projected: 4,587 | 2022 Points Scored: 2,649
Hitting Rank: 20th | Rotation Rank: 20th | Bullpen Rank: 17th
20. Atlanta Braves
2023 Points Projected: 4,593 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,814
Hitting Rank: 18th | Rotation Rank: 21st | Bullpen Rank: 22nd
TIER 4: ON THE PLAYOFF BUBBLE
19(17). Arizona Diamondbacks
2023 Points Projected: 5,092 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,002
Hitting Rank: 14th | Rotation Rank: 19th | Bullpen Rank: 20th
18(19). Milwaukee Brewers
2023 Points Projected: 5,184 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,647
Hitting Rank: 23rd | Rotation Rank: 14th | Bullpen Rank: 8th
17(11). San Diego Padres
2023 Points Projected: 5,313 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,082
Hitting Rank: 19th | Rotation Rank: 11th | Bullpen Rank: 21st
16. Los Angeles Angels
2023 Points Projected: 5,466 | 2022 Points Scored: 5,805
Hitting Rank: 15th | Rotation Rank: 6th | Bullpen Rank: 28th
15(18). Detroit Tigers
2023 Points Projected: 5,490 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,701
Hitting Rank: 11th | Rotation Rank: 18th | Bullpen Rank: 19th
14(15). Miami Marlins
2023 Points Projected: 5,654 | 2022 Points Scored: 5,938
Hitting Rank: 16th | Rotation Rank: 12th | Bullpen Rank: 10th
13(12). Los Angeles Dodgers
2023 Points Projected: 5,720 | 2022 Points Scored: 5,829
Hitting Rank: 6th | Rotation Rank: 13th | Bullpen Rank: 24th
12(14). Colorado Rockies
2023 Points Projected: 5,733 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,105
Hitting Rank: 17th | Rotation Rank: 15th | Bullpen Rank: 14th
11(13). Texas Rangers
2023 Points Projected: 5,815 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,832
Hitting Rank: 4th | Rotation Rank: 17th | Bullpen Rank: 16th
TIER 3: LIKELY TO PUNCH THEIR TICKET
10. Cleveland Guardians
2023 Points Projected: 5,986 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,480
Hitting Rank: 12th | Rotation Rank: 16th | Bullpen Rank: 7th
9(8). Cincinnati Reds
2023 Points Projected: 6,007 | 2022 Points Scored: 4,683
Hitting Rank: 13th | Rotation Rank: 10th | Bullpen Rank: 12th
8(9). Houston Astros
2023 Points Projected: 6,240 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,390
Hitting Rank: 8th | Rotation Rank: 9th | Bullpen Rank: 13th
TIER 2: THE CONTENDERS
7(5). Toronto Blue Jays
2023 Points Projected: 6,666 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,744
Hitting Rank: 7th | Rotation Rank: 1st | Bullpen Rank: 11th
6. St. Louis Cardinals
2023 Points Projected: 6,758 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,096
Hitting Rank: 10th | Rotation Rank: 7th | Bullpen Rank: 4th
5(4). Washington Nationals
2023 Points Projected: 7,057 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,699
Hitting Rank: 5th | Rotation Rank: 2nd | Bullpen Rank: 5th
4(3). Chicago White Sox
2023 Points Projected: 7,127 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,082
Hitting Rank: 9th | Rotation Rank: 4th | Bullpen Rank: 1st
3(7). Baltimore Orioles
2023 Points Projected: 7,172 | 2022 Points Scored: 3,823
Hitting Rank: 3rd | Rotation Rank: 3rd | Bullpen Rank: 9th
TIER 1: THE WORLD SERIES FAVORITES
2(1). Seattle Mariners
2023 Points Projected: 7,346 | 2022 Points Scored: 7,389
Hitting Rank: 2nd | Rotation Rank: 8th | Bullpen Rank: 2nd
1(2). San Francisco Giants
2023 Points Projected: 7,554 | 2022 Points Scored: 6,961
Hitting Rank: 1st | Rotation Rank: 5th | Bullpen Rank: 3rd